Violent Manifestations of Gender Discrimination

Dear friends, if I were to show you some newspaper clippings regarding cases of violence against women in different forms, you would in all probability remind me that piling up evidence for something everyone accepts was totally unnecessary and uncalled for. As a matter of fact, such news till recently evoked little emotional or intellectual response, since these incidents, which I choose to describe as violent manifestations of gender discrimination, were hardly ever considered to be shocking, but (and also, maybe, because) they form an enormously sizeable component of the total crimes committed. Undoubtedly, representing such acts as contemptible and shameful in literary writings as well as in social circles and from political podia is the need of the hour. However, one notices that many times the spirit of these representations is more of ascribing the violent manifestations to some quasi-mystical psycho-sexual forces than of identifying the specific ideational patterns having a common source in the problem of inequality and imbalance in man-woman relationship in a socio-historical context.

 

My humble submission is that instead of viewing violence against women as a syndrome caused by mysterious psycho-sexual compulsions in men, we had better understand that imbalance of power between men and women may be a basic cause. If we begin to view such incidents as violent and explosive manifestations of certain ideas which have become a part and parcel of the mindset of men (and, as one should notice, surprisingly also of many women), we are likely to have a more reasonable perspective. Further, it would be helpful to disentangle some distinctly identifiable patterns in the social manifestations of this structured inequality of status. Here I intend to identify three such patterns.

 

One form of oppression can be traced back to the irrational notions and discriminatory attitudes obtaining in tribal and feudal-patriarchal societies, where the very consciousness of inequality as something unjust is largely erased. Inequality may also be disguised or legitimised or even sublimated, as in the case of sati, or as shown in Satyajit Ray's Devi. Even the seemingly refined and sophisticated code of chivalry, focussing on women's 'vulnerability' is not an antithesis to the feudal code.

 

The second pattern of violence emerges from the extended application of the ethos of the market-place to man-woman relationship. Bride-burning, dowry deaths, female foeticide and wife-beating gain social legitimacy under the perverse logic of consumerism. Even women, as mothers-in-law, for example, may become instruments of betrayal, having interiorised the distortions of the consumerist ethos.

 

The third pattern of brutalities against women can be understood in terms of 'ideological' displacement or transposition operating behind gangrapes, custodial rapes, sexual crimes during communal and other kinds of riots and atrocities committed for ethnic vendetta. Scores are settled in such cases by heaping indignities upon women, who are regarded as no better than 'trophies', and by making them scapegoats in combats in which they are not directly involved.

 

It may be pointed out here that very often the vestigial presence of an old pattern causes overlapping and compounding of patterns, which may then reinforce one another. The three patterns identified here are, in my view, more commonly operative in incidents of reported and unreported violence against women than other possible ideational patterns one might locate.  

 

 

 

 

आ गया हेमंत सुन्दर

कालिदास के ऋतुसंहार (सर्ग ४, श्लोक ८५) में हेमंत ऋतु का वर्णन:

प्रभूतशालिप्रसवैश्चितानि
मृगांगनायूथविभूषितानि
मनोहरक्रौंचनिनादितानि
सीमांतरान्युत्सुकयन्ति चेतः

(श्लोक की अंतिम पंक्ति में एक अशुद्धि है. कम्प्यूटर की विवशता समझें.)

अब इसका हिंदी में भावानुवाद देखिये:

धान की भरपूर फसलों की बिछी है एक चादर

हिरनियों के झुण्ड वन में घूमते निश्चिन्त हो कर
गूंजता है गगन में अब क्रौंच का कलरव मनोहर
जा रहा है क्षितिज के उस पार सब से दूर सत्वर
आ गया हेमंत सुन्दर! 

शुक्र है .....

शुक्र है कि बच्चे अभी लड़ते हैं
वे खूब गुस्सा करते हैं
आपस में ही नहीं, माँ-बाप से भी
दूसरों से ही नहीं, अपने आप से भी
उन्हें गुस्सा आता है
अंदर से निकलता है,
चेहरे पर बिखर जाता है
आँखों में, हाथों में
साफ़ दिख जाता है.

कितनी खुशी की बात है
कि हमारे नन्हे-मुन्ने
नहीं होते हमारी तरह
समझौता-परस्त
शातिर, काइयाँ और घुन्ने!